Tires & Automotive

Why is it so hard to buy tires online?

Buying tires online is hard because orders depend on a size code most drivers cannot recite. The answer is printed on the tires already on the car.
credit card and keyboard buying something online

The call comes in on a Saturday morning. A customer stands next to the car, phone to one ear, reading the side of a tire to your support agent: two, two, five, slash, six, five, R, seventeen. Then they ask whether the smaller characters after it matter. They do: 102H is the load index and speed rating, and ordering without them can lead to the wrong tire.

In a tire store, a technician walks out, reads the sidewall and checks it against the car. Buying tires online means the shopper has to make that decision on their own, often from a menu. The store finds out it went wrong when the tires reach the installer. Yet the answer was printed on a tire the shopper already owns.

What makes online tire sales different from other e-commerce?

Fit decides a tire order, and most shoppers have to look up the code that defines it. USTMA’s tire care guide asks for the original size designation, never less load capacity, and at least the original speed rating where one is specified.

The sale is often split between two businesses. The online store sells the tire, a local shop mounts it, and the person choosing the tire never sees the car. Online sales made up 14% of US replacement tire sales in early 2023, up from 9% in 2019, according to Circana.

Which tire size should an online order use?

An online order should use the size the vehicle maker specified, checked against the tires on the car today. Those facts sit in three places that do not always agree. A year, make and model lookup returns the original options. One tire size database lists three original sizes across 13 trims of the 2025 Toyota RAV4.

The tire placard, usually on the driver’s door edge, shows the size the car was built with. The tire size on the sidewall shows what is mounted now, which may be a previous owner’s larger fitment.

The sidewall matters most when only part of a set is replaced. In a 2025 Circana survey, a third of consumers said they had replaced one or two tires instead of four to save money. The new tires should match the ones staying on the car, and a vehicle lookup cannot see them.

Size menus drop information too. A 225/65R17 tire comes as a standard-load version with load index 102 and an extra-load version with 106. A shopper who stops at three numbers can order less load capacity than the car came with. Three boxes have no field to catch it. Tony Mann, managing director of UK tire sales platform Tyrescope, gave his UK estimate on Anyline’s Auto Tech Show in 2024:

"it's about 25% e-commerce return rate at the moment so people are buying tyres and getting the wrong ones… it's 25%, a huge cost"

Tony Mann

Managing Director, Tyrescope (UK)

How do online tire stores find the right tire size?

Online tire stores usually collect the size in one of five ways, and each fails in a different place.

ApproachWhat the shopper needsWhat the store getsWhere it goes wrongBest fit
Typed size fieldThe size, from memory or the sidewallWhatever was typedTypos, and load index or speed rating left outRepeat buyers who know their size
Size menu (width, ratio, rim)Three numbersA size without load index or speed ratingStandard-load and extra-load tires look identicalPrice comparison for a known size
Year, make, model, and trim lookupThe exact trimThe original size optionsSeveral sizes per model, and no view of what is mounted nowShoppers away from the car (lookup wins here)
Support call or chatTime, and a phone at the carA size read aloud by the shopperStaff hours and mishearingStaggered or unusual fitments (people win here)
Phone camera reads the sidewallThe car, a phone and legible letteringThe full size string from the tire itselfCopies a wrong fitment a previous owner chose; browser cameras vary by deviceShoppers at the car, partial replacements
Five ways an online store collects the tire size. The vehicle lookup and the support call do things a camera cannot.

A store that asks for the vehicle and reads the sidewall can flag a mismatch before checkout.

What should you look for in a tire size scanner for an online store?

Look for a reader that runs in the browser, returns the whole size string and copes with real sidewalls.

It runs in the browser

Anyline’s Web SDK reads the tire size inside a web page, so the shopper needs no app. Ask any vendor to show it working in a phone browser, beside a parked car.

It returns the whole size string

The documented Web SDK result for a sample tire reads 275/35 R22 104W, load index and speed rating included. Test each vendor with a tire marked XL and check whether the load index reaches your search results.

It reads real sidewalls

Sidewall lettering is molded black on black, and often dirty. Anyline’s tire size scanning page states that it reads embossed, low-contrast, angled and upside-down text. Try each tool on a dirty tire at an angle before you trust its demo images.

Tireweb, an Australian company with a strong US presence, builds e-commerce sites and apps for tire wholesalers and retailers. It replaced the dropdown menus in its size search with a camera function built on Anyline. CEO Matthew Walker said it “significantly improved data accuracy and simplified the tire selection process.” Engineering teams can start with the tire size scanner integration guide. The tire e-commerce page adds vehicle identification for online stores.

What should the installer check when online tires arrive?

The installer should check each delivered tire’s size, load index and speed rating against the order and the car before mounting it. A wrong tire can still go back before mounting, and usually not after.

The full DOT code sits on the outboard sidewall. Its last four digits give the production week and year. Recording it for each wheel position lets the shop find the car if that batch is ever recalled. The TireBuddy App handles this tire and vehicle identification on a phone and keeps both codes with the vehicle record.

Frequently asked questions

Is it wise to buy tires online?

Yes, if the order matches the vehicle and a qualified shop mounts the tires. The risk sits in the selection, because a size menu lets a shopper pick a lower load index or speed rating without noticing. Check the order against the tire placard and the tires already on the car. Then have the installer check the delivered tires against the order before mounting.

Is it cheaper to buy tires online?

Sometimes, but compare the installed price. An online order adds mounting, balancing, valve stems and disposal at the installer, which a local store may include in its quote. Price the same tire, with the same load index and speed rating, in both places. Circana data from early 2023 showed average online tire prices up 54% over three years, against 32% in stores.

What is the 3% rule for tires?

The 3% rule is a fitment habit. It keeps a different tire size within about 3% of the original overall diameter, so the new tire turns at nearly the same rate per mile. No regulation or tire standard publishes it, and we found no primary source. USTMA’s stricter guidance asks for the original size designation or a maker-approved option, never less load capacity, and leaves other sizes to a tire professional.

Can you return tires bought online?

Usually, if they have not been mounted or driven. Two large US online tire retailers accept unused tires within 30 days of delivery and deduct freight from the refund. One charges $20 per tire and excludes any mounted tire, as its return policy states. A size error found after mounting is hard to undo. The cheapest place to catch it is the installer’s bay, before the first tire goes on a rim.